Lamb gave "I Do Not Hook Up" a four-star rating, stating that "Kelly Clarkson proves she knows her way all around a melodic rock song, and you will find yourself singing along. She imagines seducing him, right on the table, and imagines the two kissing. The song had some success in Australia, where it peaked at number nine on the kelly clarkson i do not hook up cover
of May 21, and held on the chart for ten weeks. Remixes Europe - MP3 download  . The New York Times Company. All she ever wanted".